Andy Robertson Faces Make-or-Break Decision That Could Define His Liverpool Legacy
Throughout the last ten years, one could easily argue that Liverpool's most successful acquisition was a young Scottish left-back named Andy Robertson.
Secured for £8 million (approximately $10 million then) from relegated Hull City, Robertson quickly emerged as a symbol of the Jürgen Klopp period. He established a formidable partnership with Trent Alexander-Arnold that would terrorize Premier League defenses for seasons ahead.
As his Liverpool journey enters its ninth season, the situation has dramatically changed. Robertson has already acknowledged he might face a tough choice when his deal ends this summer, though these discussions appear to have moved up to the January transfer period.
Tottenham Hotspur have decided not to wait for Robertson's contract expiration and are now pursuing an immediate transfer valued at up to £5 million, eager to offer the Scotsman an opportunity to rediscover his peak performance.
While this move appears logical at first glance, there are also substantial concerns regarding Robertson's future destination.
Why Could Robertson Leave Liverpool?
Why Could Robertson Leave Liverpool?
Robertson's worries about his Liverpool circumstances are genuine.
"I'm someone who needs to play," Robertson stated recently.
"I've competed through injuries. I've played when I wasn't completely healthy. I've performed when I was only at 50, 40, 30% fitness for this team and my nation. I always desire to be on the field competing and clearly that's not occurring now, so that's the difference."
Following a challenging adjustment to new manager Arne Slot's system last season, Robertson was displaced from the starting eleven by summer recruit Milos Kerkez, a £40 million signing from Bournemouth. With Kerkez recently celebrating his 22nd birthday and Robertson approaching a decade older, the situation seemed inevitable.
Atlético Madrid attempted to capitalize last summer, presenting Robertson with an immediate exit opportunity. The Scotsman chose to remain and compete for his spot but seems to be gradually accepting the reality.
The Risks of Tottenham Transfer
The Risks of Tottenham Transfer
Beyond his immediate goal of consistent playing time, Robertson aims to secure not only a place in Scotland's World Cup roster—it would require a major disaster for him to be excluded—but to reach the tournament in optimal condition.
Leaving Liverpool, where his family has established roots, would only happen if Robertson believes he'll receive more opportunities elsewhere. Tottenham offers the level of prestige he seeks, though the competition for minutes could be even fiercer.
Under Thomas Frank, the left-back position has primarily been occupied by Djed Spence, an undervalued performer from last season who has struggled to meet expectations this campaign.
Spence is actually filling in for Italy international Destiny Udogie, still regarded as one of football's most promising young talents when he maintains consistent fitness. Udogie has already suffered two injuries this season and is just beginning his comeback.
Ben Davies and new acquisition Souza are also available, but the veteran has recently sustained a serious injury while the 19-year-old is viewed as a future prospect. Robertson would easily surpass both without difficulty.
The competition with Udogie represents Robertson's primary challenge. Would Frank be willing to slow the progress of a future star for an aging veteran? Given Spurs' current difficulties, Robertson's experience could prove invaluable, but the fight for minutes feels remarkably similar to his Liverpool situation with Kerkez.
Robertson must also consider Spurs' tactical approach. Frank switched to a three-center-back formation on Saturday against Burnley, using Spence as a wing-back. The physical demands of this role—seemingly perfect for Udogie—might not suit Robertson's strengths.
Liverpool's Plan to Replace Robertson
Liverpool's Plan to Replace Robertson
Liverpool leadership reportedly maintains a close relationship with Robertson and any separation this month will only occur if it benefits both sides.
Though Liverpool would gain little from Robertson's potential exit during a period when Joe Gomez serves as the only experienced backup across center-back, left-back and right-back positions, the Reds are already preparing to address his upcoming absence.
Kostas Tsimikas, Robertson's understudy since 2020, moved to Roma on loan last summer after dropping to third choice, but discussions are underway about recalling a player who hasn't displayed his finest form during his temporary stint in Italy.
Liverpool, Roma and Tsimikas are all reportedly willing to reach an agreement, leaving the ultimate decision to Robertson at one of his career's most crucial crossroads.