From Old Trafford to Camp Nou: Rating Every Manchester United Star Who Made the Barcelona Switch

From Old Trafford to Camp Nou: Rating Every Manchester United Star Who Made the Barcelona Switch

Barcelona and Manchester United stand among the most prestigious and celebrated clubs in world football.

It was at Barcelona's Camp Nou where United secured their second European title in 1999, though the Catalan giants later prevented them from claiming a fourth European Cup/Champions League trophy on two separate occasions.

Pep Guardiola's dominant team secured a 2–0 triumph in the 2009 final held in Rome, before delivering an exceptional display in the championship match two years afterward.

Despite these connections, transfer dealings between the clubs have been remarkably rare. Prior to Marcus Rashford's season-long loan move with a purchase option, only two Manchester United players had ever made the switch to Barcelona.

Here's a look back at those two players and their experiences in Catalonia.

Mark Hughes

Mark Hughes

Welsh forward Hughes became only the second British player to wear Barcelona's colors since 1923, following Scottish striker Steve Archibald who had joined the Spanish club two years earlier in 1984.

The Manchester United academy graduate arrived in the same transfer window as Gary Lineker following the 1986 World Cup, with English coach Terry Venables leading a British influx at Camp Nou.

Hughes had emerged through United's youth system as a teenager, spending his first six professional seasons at Old Trafford before being compelled to join Barcelona due to contractual disagreements with the Red Devils.

"I lacked the confidence to refuse and things escalated until I found myself boarding a flight to Barcelona," Hughes later revealed, indicating his reluctance to leave United. While Archibald and Lineker both thrived immediately in Spain, Hughes found it difficult to settle both professionally and personally.

The Welsh striker managed only four goals during his sole La Liga campaign, ultimately returning to Manchester United in 1988 after a temporary stint with Bayern Munich. Hughes would later net a decisive double for the Red Devils against his former team in the 1991 European Cup Winners' Cup final.

Gerard Piqué

Gerard Piqué

In contrast to Hughes, Piqué was well-acquainted with Barcelona's environment when he returned in 2008. The center-back had trained at La Masia as a defensive midfielder before moving to Manchester United as a 17-year-old in 2004.

The Spanish defender made only 12 Premier League appearances during his four-year stay in Manchester, returning to Catalonia after helping win the Champions League in 2007–08.

"I'm delighted to return, I never expected to be here again, but this is wonderful for me," Piqué commented upon rejoining Barcelona. While he couldn't break past Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidić at United, Piqué quickly established himself under Guardiola upon his homecoming. He featured 45 times across all competitions for the historic sextuple-winning team in 2008–09, eventually developing into one of the world's premier center-backs during the 2010s.

Piqué spent his entire remaining career at Barcelona until 2022, accumulating 616 matches (fifth-highest in club history) and winning over 30 major trophies. He earned five UEFA Team of the Year selections and four FIFPro World XI inclusions. Piqué concluded his career as one of the greatest defenders of his era.