Gary Neville Demands Pochettino Offload These Three Players to Save Man Utd

Gary Neville Demands Pochettino Offload These Three Players to Save Man Utd

Manchester United icon Gary Neville is throwing his support behind Mauricio Pochettino to stick with Luke Shaw, Diogo Dalot and Harry Maguire as the new manager begins his tenure at Old Trafford.

However, with the backline now long overdue for reinforcement following two consecutive summers that prioritized attackers and then midfielders, the former Red Devils skipper believes it would be sensible to offload Lisandro Martínez, Matthijs de Ligt and Noussair Mazraoui.

Neville was speaking on Stick to United, filling in for regular co-host Wayne Rooney while he takes part in the U.K. reality series I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here. During a discussion with co-host Mark Goldbridge, Neville began explaining why he feels Dalot receives unfair criticism.

The Portuguese right back was met with jeers at Old Trafford during the 4–4 thriller against Aston Villa. Neville conceded that Dalot ultimately lacks the quality demanded at this level, but insisted he could not question the fullback's dedication or willingness to operate out of position—the retired defender openly acknowledged he would have struggled considerably in his own playing days if forced to play at left back.

Neville argued that Dalot's bigger issue stems from being let down by the players around him.

"I'd be getting Mazraoui well gone before [Dalot]. I'd be getting Martínez gone well before him. I'd be getting De Ligt gone well before him," Neville stated.

While Goldbridge mounted a case for De Ligt, Neville highlighted "one big problem" with the Dutchman. "He doesn't play ... You want someone who's actually reliable. De Ligt has to go." De Ligt has only recently returned from nearly a year on the sidelines with a back problem, and he hasn't surpassed 29 league appearances in a single season since 2022–23 with Bayern Munich.

Why Shaw, Maguire Will Survive Defensive Cull

Harry Maguire, Luke Shaw

A wholesale overhaul of the defense simply isn't feasible. So, even if Martínez, De Ligt and Mazraoui are moved on ahead of next season—or earlier—Pochettino will need to lean on the current squad at least in the near term.

Neville noted that Shaw could appeal to Pochettino as a player he previously guided with considerable success at Southampton, even if that was now over 12 years ago. Maguire may fall short of the elite center back standard that Virgil van Dijk set at Liverpool, but he remains a dependable "soldier."

"[Pochettino] will keep Shaw because he knows him and he'll probably get the best out of him," Neville said. "The problem with Luke is injuries, so he'll have to manage him. He'll [also] have to bring a left back in. But let's just say who he'll keep. 

"He'll keep Shaw. He'll keep Maguire because he'll trust him and he'll think that he's basically a soldier and someone who can do a job for him."

At this point, Leny Yoro is also a player worth believing in. The young Frenchman, still just 21, was heralded as a generational prospect when United outmaneuvered Real Madrid in the transfer market to secure him from Lille in 2024. He also made his France debut in October and held onto his spot in the squad for November's now-finished international break.

Neville suggested Pochettino will see Yoro as raw material he can "work with" to shape and develop. "He's a little bit gangly, all over the place right now. He's got that sort of Bambi-on-ice [look]. He'll go one way or the other. I like the fact he's been brought into the French team. It tells me sometimes you just have got to connect the dots and think, 'Well, if [France] thinks he's good, then we must be missing something here because we're not seeing it yet.'"

New Defenders Man Utd Could Sign

Alex Freeman

Yet even with Shaw, Dalot and Maguire deemed worth retaining, Neville is firm that "three [new] defenders to go above them" will be necessary.

That would presumably mean a new first-choice right back, left back and center back, with the aforementioned trio primarily serving as cover or rotation options.

Calvin Bassey of Fulham and Jarrad Branthwaite—the latter the target of several United bids rejected by Everton in the summer of 2024—are two center backs already being mentioned. Brentford's Nathan Collins is another name appearing on the early shortlist.

Alejandro Balde has slipped to third choice in Barcelona's left back pecking order and is expected to be available as early as January. The Spaniard has delivered strong campaigns in the past, but his sudden drop to the fringes has come as a surprise. USMNT left back Antonee Robinson has been linked since the summer and is clearly a familiar face to Pochettino, though he would represent a short-term fix rather than a lasting solution.

On the right back front, Denzel Dumfries is evidently not José Mourinho's first pick at Real Madrid and may already be weighing his future. The Dutchman arrived in Spain as a free agent over the summer, meaning any transfer would generate a quick return for Los Blancos. Alex Freeman enjoyed a breakout World Cup under Pochettino, is making his mark in a top-five European league with Villarreal, and is likely to come at a lower price than most alternatives.

Don't miss a story

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox.