How a $2 Billion Blow From a Guilty Verdict Could Shatter Man City's Transfer Ambitions

How a $2 Billion Blow From a Guilty Verdict Could Shatter Man City's Transfer Ambitions

Manchester City have reportedly had a $2 billion loan from Apollo Global Management "fall through" after being found guilty of more than 100 violations of the Premier League's financial rules in September.

Following a lengthy and drawn-out investigation, an independent panel determined that City had arranged "fraudulent contracts," fabricated "bogus agreements" and entered into "sham commercial deals" to "artificially inflate" revenues by over $1 billion between 2009 and 2018.

City have hit back strongly, vehemently asserting their innocence while consistently referencing "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence." This collection of documents and bank statements is believed to form the cornerstone of City's ongoing appeal and is the reason all current club employees remain so assured of their innocence. That confidence is far less widespread beyond the boundaries of east Manchester.

Apollo had been preparing to inject $2 billion into the City Football Group (CFG), a network of clubs centered around the Premier League side, with the deal reportedly in its "final stages." However, the Financial Times reports that the deal has now collapsed. The official ruling of City's guilt in the long-running Premier League case, despite the pending appeal, has been cited as the primary reason for this reversal.

Manchester City's influential chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak boldly claimed that CFG and its 11 clubs were collectively valued at no less than $10 billion just months before the guilty verdict was handed down. Even at that valuation, the loss of $2 billion in investment will be deeply felt across the entire organization.

What Was the $2 Billion Loan Going to Be Used for?

Manchester City owner Abu Dhabi royal Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan applauds.

As the old saying goes: if you want to become a millionaire, start with a billion and buy a soccer club. As City's owner Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan has come to learn, running a franchise in this sport does not come cheap.

There is a case to be made that Sheikh Mansour didn't enter the game to turn a profit—as a member of the Abu Dhabi royal family, which controls the Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG), an investment vehicle with billions in assets, there is little additional financial gain to be pursued.

Nevertheless, City's ownership has continued to seek outside investment over the years as a means of strengthening internal operations while demonstrating to the wider world just how much their investment has grown in value. U.S. private equity firm Silver Lake acquired a minority stake in CFG for a reported $500 million in 2019, valuing the group of clubs at $4.8 billion.

The FT reports that the $2 billion lined up from Apollo was intended to "refinance existing credit facilities" and provide "extra liquidity"—meaning the ability to generate additional cash for routine day-to-day operations, including funds earmarked for potential transfer activity.

What Now for Man City Transfers?

Rayan Cherki of Manchester City gestures, looking dejected.

Sheikh Mansour was reported to have pumped £100 million ($131.5 million) of equity into City Football Group through his Newton Investment and Development vehicle at the end of October. It remains unclear whether this was a direct response to Apollo's withdrawn investment, though it has widely been interpreted as such.

While that nine-figure sum is far from insignificant, it falls well short of the $2 billion City had been anticipating from Apollo. The FT highlights a growing sense of "uncertainty" surrounding the club's financial outlook amid the ongoing Premier League charges.

Should City's appeal be unsuccessful, the club could face a range of penalties, with relegation considered a near-certainty if a severe points deduction is imposed. The revenue lost from dropping out of both the Premier League and Champions League could run into hundreds of millions of dollars, with the reputational damage potentially proving even more costly.

There are not believed to be any relegation clauses in players' contracts, but previous demotions of top-flight clubs have demonstrated how rarely star players remain for a stint in the second division. If Apollo's pulled investment signals a broader pattern, City may lack the financial firepower to prevent a mass departure.

Don't miss a story

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox.