Liverpool are facing what has been called an "increasingly complicated" goalkeeping situation regarding the choice between Alisson and Giorgi Mamardashvili. Ultimately, the most practical resolution may lie in a third option entirely.
Alisson has been Liverpool's decorated first-choice goalkeeper since 2018, guiding the club to every major honour within reach and establishing himself as one of the finest shot-stoppers of his generation — or perhaps any generation. Yet even the bearded Brazilian cannot escape the march of time.
The injuries that plagued him even during his peak years have become increasingly damaging, resulting in a string of inconsistent performances this season. As he showed against Crystal Palace before the international break, Alisson remains capable of brilliance. However, his error-riddled outing in the loss to Fenerbahçe four days prior highlights the volatility in his form.
Liverpool had moved to address this inevitability by securing Mamardashvili as far back as 2024. The Georgian goalkeeper would spend an additional year on loan at Valencia before entering into direct competition with Alisson during the 2025–26 campaign. Mamardashvili was handed opportunities due to his teammate's inconsistent fitness, but struggled to capitalise on them, never quite establishing himself as the stronger option.
The 26-year-old has grown frustrated with lingering in the background during what should be the peak years of his career, and is expected to push for a definitive decision, according to Fabrizio Romano. Adding further complexity to the situation, Alisson has publicly stated his desire to extend a contract that runs out next summer.
Andoni Iraola now finds himself managing a fading starter and a restless understudy unwilling to remain on the sidelines indefinitely.
Should Liverpool part ways with Alisson, they would need to trust that Mamardashvili flourishes with the confidence of being the undisputed No. 1. However, if they were to move on from a goalkeeper who has retained considerable market value, there is already an option available to Iraola next summer that could work alongside a potential Alisson extension.
Liverpool Have Already Bought the Solution

Liverpool invested €30 million ($33 million at current rates) in Mamardashvili, a move widely seen as a bold statement of intent in their succession planning for Alisson. Yet when the Reds spent an identical fee on Genk's Belgian teenage prospect Lucca Brughmans this past summer, the signing barely made a ripple.
After claiming a starting berth in the Belgian top flight at just 18 years old, Brughmans attracted the attention of Europe's biggest clubs. Liverpool won the race to sign the towering 6'7" goalkeeper, who grew up idolising Thibaut Courtois, before sending him back to Belgium for the 2026–27 season.
"Ultimately, the goal is to become the first-choice keeper at Liverpool," Brughmans stated at his low-key unveiling. "To get there, I still need to develop, and Genk is the best place to do that." Just days after his swift return from signing his contract in England, the teenager produced two vital saves to earn a point and a clean sheet against Royal Antwerp.
There is a composed mentality to match an impressive physical presence in a teenager brimming with potential. Liverpool clearly believe in his ability — that transfer fee alone speaks volumes in today's market — and could take the bold step of having him develop under Alisson next season. Courtois serves as a particularly relevant reference point for Brughmans, having himself emerged at Chelsea with serial Premier League winner Petr Čech as a mentor and training partner to draw from.
"We do not like change for the sake of change," was the mantra Liverpool's former chairman John Smith was fond of repeating. "We like continuity." Yet nothing, not even Alisson, can go on forever.
ไทย
English
中國人