Inter Miami's Supporters' Shield ambitions suffered a significant setback on Saturday evening, as league-leaders Nashville SC netted a stoppage-time equalizer to claim a 2–2 draw and extend their nine-point advantage over the Herons.
While the deficit Miami needs to overcome remains unchanged, the South Florida club now has only nine matches remaining to close the gap, and a defeat to San Diego FC next week could drop the Herons as low as fifth in the standings.
However, there's little fault to assign to Lionel Messi. The sole MLS nominee for the 2026 Ballon d'Or netted his 19th goal of the campaign with a breathtaking, curling strike from beyond the penalty box, one of eight shots he attempted on the evening.
Surridge equalizes in stoppage! 😳
Nashville and Miami searching for a winner late! pic.twitter.com/hkjmF1bHJz
As has frequently been the case for Miami, however, a shortage of support around Messi defined the contest, with Nashville's Sam Surridge completing a brace via goals in the fourth and 91st minutes to earn a share of the points.
Here, Sports Illustrated examines Miami's ongoing difficulties as their recent form slipped to just one victory in the past seven outings.
Berterame's Struggles and Miami's Finishing

This match illustrated just how potent Miami could be if Germán Berterame delivered on his striker potential. For the opposition, Surridge demonstrated his clinical edge as the finest pure striker in MLS, capitalizing on two clear opportunities on a night Nashville never truly dominated.
By contrast, Berterame squandered three attempts and had one effort blocked, highlighting his inability to convert chances and the hesitation he displayed even when well-positioned to score. With a shooting percentage of just 14% this season, it raises serious questions about where Miami might stand if they had a finisher of Surridge's caliber in their ranks.
While the finishing woes have largely centered on Berterame, Messi, Rodrigo De Paul, and others also spurned key opportunities on Saturday, with the Herons striking the woodwork three times on otherwise gilt-edged chances. Those misses dragged their shot-conversion rate for the season down to 40%.
Without crucial contributions from players beyond Messi in high-pressure moments, the upcoming big matches—beginning with the Campeones Cup one-game final on Wednesday—will only grow more demanding.
Messi Loves Nashville, but Is He Miami's Only Hope?

Messi has a particular fondness for facing Nashville. Across just 14 appearances, he has found the net 17 times—the Tennessee club are the only non-Spanish opponent he has scored more than 10 goals against.
While the dominance began in the 2023 Leagues Cup final and has included commanding Miami victories in the MLS Cup playoffs, the rivalry has also seen Nashville thrash Miami 4–1 in regular-season play earlier this year and eliminate the Herons from the Concacaf Champions Cup.
Messi. Left foot. 20 yards out. 🐐
Miami takes the lead on Nashville! pic.twitter.com/DuBJI7gxOz
"God gave him this gift," interim boss Guillermo Hoyos said of Messi's display, a sentiment he has frequently echoed rather than addressing his team's broader performance. "He's a one-of-a-kind player; he's one of a kind. He cannot be repeated."
The concerning reality for Miami, however, is that Nashville have proven to be the superior side on every occasion this season, and the Herons would almost certainly need to eliminate them in the playoffs to have any chance of advancing from the Eastern Conference. At this stage, one must question whether any of Miami's other talents possess the ability to step up and deliver against the undisputed best team in the league.
Frustrations Boiling Over

There is plenty fueling frustration at Inter Miami right now. A third consecutive draw, and seven winless outings from eight, is just one element, with the added sting of conceding a late equalizer to a direct rival making it all the more painful.
Compounding matters, Kily González was appointed as the new head coach on Aug. 27 yet still lacks the necessary U.S. work permits to assume the position. In the meantime, Hoyos continues to manage a struggling side from the touchline and, understandably, faces growing backlash from supporters. After all, this is a club carrying enormous expectations that have gone unmet for nearly two months.
While fan frustration is plain to see, it appears to have filtered through to the players as well. Late in the midweek draw against the Chicago Fire, a confrontation erupted between Rodrigo De Paul and Robert Lewandowski, with others quickly getting involved. Similar incidents occurred in the Quinn Sullivan-Ian Fray altercation in Philadelphia and the Alonso Coello incident in the defeat to Toronto FC.
This past weekend, new recruit and Paraguay World Cup standout Matías Galarza picked up a yellow card for kicking the ball away following a foul, disrupting Miami's late momentum and allowing the team's composure to unravel when they needed to hold firm. Shortly after, De Paul put in a half-hearted defensive effort tracking back, which ultimately contributed to Surridge's equalizer.
Frustrations are causing Inter Miami to unravel at present, and it will require a run of positive results to restore their confidence. Fortunately, the upcoming schedule offers San Diego FC and D.C. United as the next two opponents—a considerably more manageable challenge than Nashville.
ไทย
English
中國人