Thomas Muller Calls Out MLS's Biggest Flaw: 'There's No Real Pressure'

Thomas Muller Calls Out MLS's Biggest Flaw: 'There's No Real Pressure'

Vancouver Whitecaps star Thomas Müller admitted that "there's no big pressure" in MLS due to the absence of a relegation system, making it impossible to compare the league to the top tiers of European soccer.

The 2014 World Cup winner and Bayern Munich icon is flourishing in his second MLS campaign, helping Vancouver claim first place in the Western Conference regular season standings. However, when asked to rank MLS alongside European leagues, the German attacking midfielder gave a revealing response.

"It's difficult to compare because of the system," Müller told Global News. "There is no relegation, there is no big pressure. There is, 'Oh yeah, we do a rebuild.' Nobody's happy to lose, but it's totally different when you fight [against] getting relegated.

"Maybe you [relegated teams] lose budget for the next year. You lose people working at the club. It's totally different for fans. The pressure. The players maybe have no contracts for next year when you go down. So the playing style changes when you play a bottom of the league team in Europe, they fight for their lives.

"And sometimes I have the feeling, because of the system [in MLS], the playing style is a little more, let's say, optimistic or careless defensively. Just a little bit, the French would say, 'laissez faire'. That's maybe good for seeing some nice offensive plays when the games are opening up.

A promotion-relegation system, however, is not something MLS is expected to implement in the near future.

Why There's No Relegation in MLS

Sporting Kansas City.

The absence of a relegation system isn't unique to MLS. It's simply embedded in American sports culture as a whole. None of the major U.S. sports leagues operate with a relegation system.

Several factors contribute to this reality, but the most significant one is financial. MLS doesn't have "teams" in the traditional sense — it has franchises. These franchises are valuable assets that require the stability of guaranteed league membership in order to grow.

If a promotion-relegation system were introduced, the threat of dropping out of MLS — devaluing the franchise and triggering the consequences that follow — could deter potential investors. This is a particularly pressing concern given that MLS is competing for attention against more established leagues in the American sports landscape, a challenge European leagues don't face.

Since its inception, MLS has focused on expanding both financially and competitively. That remains the primary objective. Adopting a relegation system would demand a complete structural overhaul, and crucially, franchise owners would need to approve such a change — an unlikely outcome given that it would introduce considerable risk to their investments.

Over the summer, incoming MLS commissioner Larry Berg dismissed the idea of introducing a relegation system, contending that it's not "a way to get stadiums built, get training facilities built and to have owners invest in rosters and all the other things you need to do."

The Negative Consequences of No Relegation in MLS

Mauricio Pochettino.

Former U.S. men's national team head coach Mauricio Pochettino drew sharp criticism after targeting American sports culture with the remark, "American sports reward losers," ahead of the 2026 World Cup.

The words were blunt, but not entirely without merit. MLS, at the very least, rewards mediocrity. Consider the MLS playoffs, where 18 of the league's 30 clubs qualify and compete for the championship.

FC Cincinnati, for instance, will face Nashville SC in the round of 16 of the 2026 Eastern Conference playoffs. Nashville topped the regular season standings with 77 points, while Cincinnati won just 12 of their 34 regular season matches and finished 31 points adrift of Nashville.

In 2024, Lionel Messi guided Inter Miami to the best regular season record, yet the Herons were eliminated by Atlanta United — who finished 34 points behind and won only 10 regular season games — in the opening round of the playoffs.

Moreover, as is common across American sports leagues, teams that finish near the bottom of the standings are rewarded with high draft picks, giving them the best opportunity to strengthen their rosters with top available talent. MLS makes a deliberate effort to promote parity among clubs — the limited number of designated player spots per team serves as further evidence of this approach.

While league parity isn't inherently negative and does provide a degree of stability, MLS may not exactly "reward losers," but it certainly doesn't punish them in any meaningful way either.

The absence of relegation safeguards stability and franchise value, but it also diminishes the stakes and competitive pressure of the league — as Müller so plainly illustrated.

Don't miss a story

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox.