USMNT Scrambles to Fill Void as Pochettino Replacement Search Exposes Critical Flaws

USMNT Scrambles to Fill Void as Pochettino Replacement Search Exposes Critical Flaws

The United States men's national team faces a difficult situation if Mauricio Pochettino is appointed as Manchester United's next manager within the next few days.

The timing works in one respect, as whoever takes over from the Argentine on a permanent basis will have nearly four complete years to build toward the 2030 World Cup. The financial windfall from Pochettino's $10 million release clause and additional compensation for his backroom staff also presents a significant opportunity, as those funds can be channeled back into the program.

But United—assuming the final call is made to part ways with Michael Carrick—would want Pochettino installed well ahead of the club's fixture against Liverpool on Nov. 22.

Separate to the Carrick situation, one of the sticking points still being worked through in negotiations is the finer details of Pochettino's potential departure. The Overlap's Mike Keegan reports that one such point is whether the 54-year-old will still lead the USMNT in two games against Haiti—in Miami and Cincinnati—as part of the Concacaf Nations League quarterfinal.

🚨 There is now a growing expectation that, should Manchester United press ahead, Mauricio Pochettino will be in the dugout for their clash at Liverpool a week on Sunday. Talks have progressed positively and are in the final stages with minor details - such as whether MP takes…

Those fixtures are scheduled for Nov. 14 and Nov. 18. If Pochettino were to remain in charge for those games, it could leave him with just one or two days to prepare before his United debut.

That makes the precise timing a small yet meaningful detail. While United can effectively bypass U.S. Soccer by triggering the $10 million clause, U.S. Soccer must now be "involved in talks" as part of the process.

Should Pochettino depart, his core coaching staff—Jesús Pérez, Miki D'Agostino, Toni Jiménez, Sebastiano Pochettino—will leave alongside him. United will need to pay additional fees to secure their releases, but this is non-negotiable for Pochettino. Wherever he goes, they follow.

This means there will be no assistant coach available to step in and fill the void in the short term.

U.S. Soccer will need to seek an interim solution to cover this month, but the two names being floated as contingency options already have significant commitments elsewhere.

USMNT's Best Interim Options Are Not Ideal

Steve Cherundolo

Steve Cherundolo, the former USMNT captain and MLS Cup-winning head coach, currently leads the Under-23 national team and is the most obvious candidate. However, the 47-year-old, who was appointed in July at the start of a two-year cycle building toward the 2028 Olympics on home soil, traveled to Spain over the weekend for a training camp running until Nov. 17.

U.S. Soccer could recall Cherundolo to oversee the senior squad, but this is literally his first camp with the U–23s, and pulling him away immediately risks undermining his early authority, squad development, and team cohesion at such a critical stage of his tenure.

The other name circulating is B.J. Callaghan. The 45-year-old previously served as a USMNT assistant and stepped up to guide the Stars and Stripes to Nations League glory three years ago during the gap between Gregg Berhalter's two stints. He has just wrapped up the 2026 Major League Soccer regular season with Nashville SC, claiming the Supporters' Shield and setting a new record points total, making him a highly credible contender for the permanent position.

However, Nashville's MLS Cup campaign kicks off on Nov. 22 in the first round of the Eastern Conference bracket. Callaghan diverting his attention from that three-game series against either Orlando City or FC Cincinnati would be an unwelcome distraction at best—and potentially catastrophic at worst.

B.J. Callaghan

U.S. Soccer still lacks a sporting director following Matt Crocker's departure in April to take on a comparable role with Saudi Arabia's football federation.

These matches carry enormous significance for U.S. Soccer. Not only has Haiti failed to defeat the USMNT since 1973, but claiming the Nations League title for a fourth time—after surrendering it to Mexico two years ago—would serve as a powerful statement of dominance in the region.

Haiti, having secured their spot at the 2026 World Cup at Costa Rica's expense, poses enough of a threat to cause real problems if American focus is even slightly elsewhere.

Don't miss a story

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox.